A REVIEW OF THE OFFICIAL OPPONENT ON FEDOR VLADIMIROVICH GRUSHIN’S THESIS “SYSTEM OF FACTORS DETERMINING THE DEVELOPMENT OF PENAL POLICY AND PENAL LEGISLATION”, SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DSC (LAW) IN THE SCIENTIFIC SPECIALTY 12.00.08 CRIMINAL LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY; PENAL LAW (EKATERINBURG, 2019, 554 P. WITH APPLICATIONS)
Received: 05.09.2019
Accepted: 28.09.2019
Published: 28.09.2019
Language of publication: ru-RU
ABSTRACT
The article presents a review of the official opponent on Fedor Vladimirovich Grushin’s thesis “System of factors determining the development of penal policy and penal legislation”, defended at the meeting of the dissertation Council at the Ural state law University on 18 April 2019. Scientific novelty of the thesis is determined by the fact that this is the first monographic study on the “crossroads” of penal policy, penal dogma and criminal sociology, which is subjected to scientific study dynamics of development of Penal legislation since the adoption of the Penal code of the Russian Federation in 1996 ‘On the basis of the dissertation factor analysis suggested a predictive assessment of the development of penal policy of the Russian Federation until 2025 (with three different scenarios)’. The methods used by the author of the thesis (comparative legal, historical, systemstructural and formallogical) testify to the necessary degree of reliability and validity of the results, the majority of which has the proper novelty. However, the work is not without a number of shortcomings, which are either private or controversial. Because Of this, V. F. Grushin’s dissertation is a scientific qualification work that has solved a scientific problem that is important for the development of the penal policy and the penal legislation.
KEYWORDS
penal policy, penal legislation, thesis